The source says Thursday. The draft says Tuesday.
A fictional email, a deliberately wrong draft and a worked correction. A copyable prompt for checking claims against their exact source.
written
The source says Thursday after 2 pm. The draft says Tuesday at 2 pm, with delivery included.
This exercise uses a fictional email and a draft with errors inserted on purpose. The task is to trace each claim back to its source before rewriting it.
The source
Your signed packet will be ready Thursday after 2 pm. Please collect it at the front desk. If someone else is collecting it, call us before sending them. No delivery has been arranged.
The deliberately wrong draft
Your packet will be delivered Tuesday at 2 pm. Anyone may collect it without calling.
Five things to check
| Draft | Exact source | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| Tuesday | Your signed packet will be ready Thursday after 2 pm. | The day |
| at 2 pm | Your signed packet will be ready Thursday after 2 pm. | An after-time becomes an exact time |
| will be delivered | No delivery has been arranged. | An unsupported delivery commitment |
| Anyone may collect it without calling. | If someone else is collecting it, call us before sending them. | The condition is reversed |
| No pickup location | Please collect it at the front desk. | An instruction is omitted |
A source-grounded revision
Your signed packet will be ready for pickup at the front desk Thursday after 2 pm. If someone else is collecting it, call us before sending them. No delivery has been arranged.
The revision keeps the original day, the after-time condition, the pickup location and the call requirement. It makes no delivery promise.
A prompt to copy
Check this draft only against the supplied source.
For each date, time, action, condition and commitment:
1. Copy the draft's claim.
2. Quote the exact source sentence that supports or conflicts with it.
3. Mark changed meaning, missing instructions and unsupported commitments.
4. Rewrite the draft using only supported information.
If the source does not establish something, leave it unknown.
Return the claim table, then the corrected draft.
SOURCE:
[paste source]
DRAFT:
[paste draft]What was checked
Codex reviewed the five claims and produced the revision above. A local Python run passed 17 literal text checks, confirming that the source quotes exist and that the supplied draft and correction match the worked example. Meaning judgments came from agent review.
The source files, review and runnable checks are on GitHub. They run with Python 3 and need no packages or API key.
This is a worked exercise with planted errors. It measures no model accuracy or time saving.
For another pass, remove the day from the source. The review should leave it unknown rather than choose a day.
I share small experiments for people bringing AI into office work on X @SangTheRhee.